Self-Publishing vs. Traditional: Pros, Cons & Path-Finding Questions

May 3

If you’ve ever googled “Should I self-publish or go traditional?” and ended up more confused than when you started—welcome. You’re not alone.

Both paths come with incredible opportunities (and very real trade-offs). The key is figuring out which one aligns with your goals, resources, and creative vision. 🧭✨

Here’s a breakdown to help you decide:

🛠️ Self-Publishing

Pros:
– Total creative control: cover, title, edits, release date—you decide.
– Faster to market: no waiting 12–24 months to launch.
– Higher royalty rates: often 60–70% of sales on platforms like Amazon KDP.
– Direct access to your readers: you build the relationship.

Cons:
– You’re the publisher (and the marketer, and the budget manager).
– Upfront costs: editing, cover design, formatting, etc.
– Discoverability is on you—there’s no built-in PR team.
– Some award and bookstore limitations (though this is changing fast).

🏛️ Traditional Publishing

Pros:
– Industry credibility and prestige.
– Professional team: editors, cover designers, marketers, distributors.
– Easier access to bookstores, libraries, and media.
– Advance payment (though often small and split in chunks).

Cons:
– Long timelines: expect 1–2 years after signing to see your book on shelves.
– Less control: you may not get final say on your title or cover.
– Lower royalty rates (often 10–15% of net sales).
– Must secure a literary agent to even get in the door.

🔍 Path-Finding Questions to Ask Yourself

1. What matters most to me—speed, control, or prestige?
If you’re looking to move fast and keep full ownership, self-pub might be your lane. If you want access to major media or award circles, traditional might fit better.

2. How comfortable am I running the business side of publishing?
Self-publishing means you wear all the hats (or hire people who do). Traditional lets you focus more on the writing—but you still need to market.

3. What’s my long-term vision as an author?
One book? Multiple series? Career novelist? Different paths support different kinds of author careers.

4. Am I open to a hybrid model?
Many modern authors do both: self-publish some titles while traditionally publishing others. You don’t have to choose just one path forever.

The bottom line?
There’s no wrong choice—only the one that’s right for you.
Self-publishing isn’t “less than,” and traditional publishing isn’t “easier.” Each requires strategy, resilience, and heart. 💛

Wherever you’re headed, make sure it’s aligned with your vision—and don’t be afraid to change lanes if the road calls for it.

Need help deciding? Schedule a mentorship call with us today!