Writing Tropes That Sell: What Readers Want in Fantasy, Romance, and Thrillers
If you’ve been told to avoid tropes at all costs, you’ve probably been given half the truth. Tropes aren’t your enemy. They’re the reason readers pick up your book in the first place. Tropes are a promise to your readers. They say, “You love stories like this? Then this is the book for you!”
It’s not about avoiding tropes. Instead, it’s all in the execution. Putting a new spin, a surprising twist, and fun, satisfying ending—intentionally choosing how to use tropes makes all the difference.
Check out what readers of these popular genres are looking for:
🌙 Fantasy: Give Them Wonder, Peril, and Secrets to Obsess Over
Fantasy readers are here to escape. They want to be dropped into a world that’s so vivid they can smell the pine forests, taste the strange festival foods, and feel the brush of dragon scales or witchfire.
The tropes that make them click buy now again and again?
Secret legacies. The farm kid with royal blood. The barmaid with outlaw magic. Readers love watching ordinary become extraordinary.
Mismatched crews. Thieves, scholars, mercenaries—forced together on a mission that could save or doom them all. It’s about the bonds, betrayals, and found family.
Dark deals. The promise that costs too much. A hero who shakes hands with something monstrous. Always a draw.
Palace games and poisoned cups. If you’ve got court politics, plots behind velvet curtains, and knives hidden in smiles, you’re speaking their language.
At the end of the day, fantasy lovers want to marvel at something and worry for someone. Tropes just give them the doorway.
❤️ Romance: Feed Their Need for Longing, Banter, and Big Emotional Payoff
Romance runs on tropes. Readers hunt for them like comfort food because they know exactly what ride they’re signing up for.
What keeps them coming back?
Enemies who can’t keep their hands off each other. The journey from “can’t stand to even look at you” to “Oh noooo, I think I’m in love” is delicious.
Fake dating or marriages of convenience. Forced closeness. Shared beds. The ache of realizing pretend might be real.
Second chances. Old flames who still burn for each other, despite the scars.
Grumpy meets sunshine. The world-weary soul who thinks joy is a scam collides with the one person who refuses to give up on them.
Romance tropes work because they guarantee certain feelings. Your job is to twist the knife just right and then heal it by the end.
🔥 Thrillers: Promise Danger, Twists, and Breathless Pacing
Thriller readers pick up a book to be unsettled, surprised, and maybe even scared. They want the tightrope walk between “I think I know what’s happening…” and “Holy crap, I did not see that coming.”
The tropes that never lose their shine:
The innocent suspect. Someone framed (or so it seems) who has to prove their own innocence before the clock runs out.
The closed circle. A murderer loose on an international flight, a botched heist trapping thieves inside—any setting where escape is impossible and every person could be hiding dangerous secrets.
The buried past. Secrets clawing their way to the surface at exactly the worst time.
The final gut-punch. That moment you drop the last puzzle piece and everything the reader thought they knew flips upside down.
Thriller fans want tension like a tight wire, and they want to fall hard when it snaps.
Want expert eyes on your story so your favorite tropes don’t fall flat?
The Iconic mentorship program is built for authors ready to level up. You’ll get personal feedback on your writing, tailored strategy for pitching and positioning your book, and a clear plan for turning your love of storytelling into a long-term career.
